Please wait while the Pandalous reader loads...
Pandalous
The Place for Intelligent Conversation
 
 
 
  
Latest Post: May 30, 2010 at 1:23 AM
8 people participating
Spans 292 days

Pandalous reproduces the college experience online, in a new universal college of everyday life. Personal development after college is usually professionally oriented and not multi-dimensional. Pandalous allows you to constantly encounter and explore new ideas and areas of life, with a diverse community of participants, from university professors and students to journalists, artists, professionals, and monks. Join us in the experience of teaching and learning.

The internet doesn't have to be a waste of time.

I've been thinking lately of trying out therapy. I'm not depressed and I'm not having an existential breakdown, but I want to see what it's all about. It's a weird thing, talking. It's a weirder thing talking to a stranger. To think that it is someone's calling to sit in a comfortable chair and listen while I spit at him all the brain stuff at the very tip of my conscious. But I know people that do it and consistently they are the happiest people I know. Might there be some secret to therapy every once in a while?

So what is there to gain by therapy? I think I mostly am interested just for that, by curiosity. If there is something that this stranger can help me find out about myself I'd like to know. I guess it might be helpful to have someone else analyze and pick apart my brain. It's like a peer editor, someone who can tell me if what I think is coming across in my rough draft really is or not. But there is a stigma attached to therapy, there's no doubt about that. I remember watching a Curb Your Enthusiasm episode where Larry sits in his therapist's office and discusses his shoes. I can't imagine Larry David talking about anything else to a therapist. What happens if that's all I am comfortable talking about? The trivialities of my every day life? Is there something to learn from that? Or is that a sign I don't belong in therapy?

Is there an ultimate goal for therapy? Is it happiness or personal understanding? Or is it for better self-analyzing? Should I go in with a goal in my mind for what I want out of therapy or should I just let the therapist ease me into whatever path is best? What worries me most about therapy is not knowing whether I am getting anything out of it. How do you gauge the benefit from therapy? I feel if I were to go try this out my hypothetical therapist would receive the most meta-patient he's ever experienced.

Again, I restate, therapy is a weird thing. It's a bit self-centered and unexplainable. But people do it, people who on the outside seem entirely content. But might there be something inside everyone worth talking to a stranger about? Underneath all of our surfaces might there not lie a monster? Is it the job of the therapist to find this monster and expel it? Or at least teach me how to keep it caged inside?

So for those on Pandalous who go to or used to go to a therapist and feel comfortable discussing it, I'd like to know all you care to divulge. What reasons are there for seeking out therapy and even what reasons are there for leaving therapy? Is it a life decision or merely something that I will need sometimes and other times not? And if I do go into therapy, how do I get everything out of it that I can? With what sort of mind should I bring to the session?

thanks in advance


Save your money.  Therapy is very expensive (mine was $12,000) but  I entered into it while going through the end of a 25 year marriage.  If you are not depressed or going through a breakdown then I don't think that what you have to gain would be worth the investment of your time and funds.  I think you are somewhat misunderstanding the purpose of therapy based on your comment about the possibility of finding a 'monster' within.  If you suspect this to be the case, then by all means venture forth, but if there is no reason for you to think this about yourself, then why go looking?  You would surely already know if it were the case. 


Today many people just want to be medicated.  Originally, psychoanalysis was a talking cure.  But I have read recently that true psychoanalysis is not really effective if you go once a week.  You are merely bringing this week's news to the therapist.  There are so many things to consider in deciding to go to analysis.  Who you go to is important.  In a sense, it can be considered a luxury for those who have the money, but sure, it can be fascinating as well as helpful towards achieving a sense of wholeness or openness in a culture that makes us want to close up more. 

If you dredge up the past in order to let it go, that's great, but if you use it to reinforce your anger, then it's a problem.  There is no easy answer to whether you should go, but I like your experimental and inquisitive approach.  I think the attitude should be to learn and to grow, and you seem to have that.  Other people go to therapy to blame other people and the therapist reinforces their isolation. 

Personally, I find insight meditation to be a great way to check into the chattering mind, and to realize how much we believe that what is going on in head is the real reality.  Any practice that allows you to live even for a moment in the here and now is useful.  Nobody can ultimately do it but you, but if you find someone that you consider to be a great therapist, it's a simple thing and it is useful. 

In other times people have had a priest, a teacher, or a confident.  Today with the electronic world there is only so far you can go with that.  Let your own intuition make up your mind for you.  And since there are no guarantees in life, a crisis will always come up that may force us into a setting where we need a little help. 

I read this post with interest because I believe it would be of great help for me to go to therapy, for the first time.  I have read many psychology related books and journals, and I wonder if it is not just fear keeping me away.  You have nothing to lose by trying it out, and remember, if it isn't good for you, it may just be one experience with one therapist.


In response to why therapy, and the questions raised.  I truly believe therapy has saved my life, more than once.  I went into therapy for first time at 19yrs old, back in 1967 when therapy was affordable and you'd see the dr 3 times a week, plus there were all kinds of interesting fun therapies to try, like the hot tubs at Esalen and some trippy things.  People weren't suing for everything and there was much more freedom.

That said, I knew when to quit therapy and we discussed it openly.  I then again returned to a different therapist when I was nearing 40, got tremendous help (yes it was an existential crisis) and stayed for about  2 yrs.  Again I knew when it was time to leave.

Now at age 61 I have just restarted therapy w/ another therapist, in response to some big personal losses and unexpected sudden retirement.  I also asked for and got an antidepressant that so far has really helped me, fingers crossed.  My husband and all friends can see the difference.

The circumstances of your life can't always be changed, but an objective trained observer can help you see things that you aren't able to see.  We never see ourselves as others see us, and while I know I have a lot of insight into myself there are times I've hit a rut, or been swamped w/ nihilistic thoughts.  When I can't get out of it and it starts to consume me, it's time for therapy.

At each time I went into therapy it was for different crises going on, but my basic personality etc can tend to the melancholic if I'm not careful.   It's always amazing to me when an antidepressant works---really kind of shocking--- but I've never had to be on one for all that long for it to do the trick and pull me out. Again, nothing has changed externally but the way I respond to it changes dramatically, from complete cynicism and seeing death everywhere to actually enjoying a day, the sun and trees and ocean.

Mindfulness meditation is tremendously helpful to me once I pull out of the quicksand.  Depression can have an anxiety component---when will I feel better? why can't i figure this out?  why can't I even try to do my mindfulness meditation w/o anxiety and feeling hopeless?

I hope that helps somebody.

Join the Community
Full Name:
Your Email:
New Password:
I Am:
Country:
By registering at Pandalous.com, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

  
Share: digg reddit delicious Facebook StumbleUpon Newsvine Mail to a FriendSubscribe to Discussion
Order:
  
Searching
No results found.